recommendations | 

Leo Varadkar compares tax and welfare proposals to 'Sinn Féin manifesto’

Mr Varadkar’s spokesperson denied he was suggesting the commission had been politicised or infiltrated by members of Sinn Féin

Tanaiste Leo Varadkar© PA

Hugh O'

TÁNAISTE Leo Varadkar has said some of the recommendations of a landmark report into the State’s tax and welfare system are “straight out of the Sinn Féin manifesto”.

He also said that certain proposals were never going to happen “while Fine Gael is in government".

But Mr Varadkar’s spokesperson subsequently denied he was suggesting the Commission on Taxation and Welfare had been politicised.

It followed remarks made by Mr Varakdar at a press conference today.

Asked about the Commission on Taxation report, which was published this afternoon, Mr Varadkar said: “I see some things in it that I absolutely agree with, like not taxing child benefit.

“They advocate that we stick to our low corporate tax regime, like the fact that they don't recommend any increases in income tax. So a lot of things that I support.

“There are other things that, quite frankly, are straight out of the Sinn Féin manifesto, you know, increasing inheritance tax, for example, increasing taxes on people's savings.

“There's no way that's going to happen, while Fine Gael is in government. So you have a mixed bag of things that I agree with, [and] things that simply won't happen, certainly not under this government.”

He described the 500-page report as “not government policy” and said there are “no plans to increase employers’ PRSI” in the forthcoming budget, but he said the proposal to reform the commercial rates system and introduce a site value tax would be “of benefit for business”.

Mr Varakar said the report, which was noted rather than approved by Cabinet on Wednesday, was a “high-quality, detailed, objective analysis of our tax system”.

In response to questions about the Tánaiste’s earlier remarks, Mr Varadkar’s spokesperson denied he was suggesting the commission had been politicised or infiltrated by members of Sinn Féin.

“It was a fairly throwaway remark, it was only about a couple of items in it,” the spokesperson said.

The Tánaiste’s spokesperson issued a further comment on Wednesday evening: “The Government thanks the Commission for its work.

“The Tánaiste pointed out correctly that some of the Commission’s recommendations are also advocated separately by Sinn Féin, including increasing inheritance taxes and taxes on people’s savings, while others reflect the views of parties such as Fine Gael, such as reforming commercial rates.

“As is the case with other commissions, the Government will accept some of the recommendations and not proceed with others.”

Meanwhile Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe has said it would be "challenging" to increase taxes on householders as called for by the expert group.

"Substantial" increases in land and property taxes, VAT hikes, congestion charges in urban areas, increased PRSI and the phasing out of relief on private health insurance premiums are among a series of measures proposed by the Commission on Taxation and Welfare.

Mr Donohoe said the Government would give "serious consideration" to the proposals but that they will not be acted on ahead of the Budget in two weeks' time.

He made the comments at the publication of the commission's completed report at Dublin City University's St Patrick's campus.

The 500-page report contains 116 recommendations aimed at increasing taxes.

"Over time, the overall level of taxation as a share of national taxes will have to increase," it says.

"It is necessary to broaden the tax base so as to limit the need for increases in tax rates and to secure the sustainability of the taxation system against future challenges."

The report described the share of taxation from property and wealth as "low" and said it should be increased.

A site value tax is also called for by the commission.

It fell short of recommending a net wealth tax but said "Capital Gains Tax and Capital Acquisitions Tax as well as taxes on land and property should be substantially increased".

Speaking at the launch of the report, Mr Donohoe said: "I do acknowledge that some of the recommendations are challenging. And as acknowledged in the report, they do come at a challenging time for many economically.

"It is certainly clear from this report that if we do over time want a bigger state then we need to find the money to pay for it."

He added: "These are clearly not easy choices. The longer-term focus here is critical and as is explicitly recognised in the report. It isn't expected and it isn't realistic to think that recommendations while interconnected should all be implemented at once.

"Rather this commission is clear that 'careful consideration' is required of their impact."

The commission, chaired by Professor Niamh Moloney, was set up in April last year to review how best the taxation and welfare system can support economic activity and income redistribution whilst prompting increased employment and prosperity in a sustainable way.

Prof Moloney said the overall level of tax action as a share of national income will have to rise over the next 10 to 15 years.

"This is not the political statement. It is simply a reflection of the age profile of our population," she said.

"To provide a level of services that as a society we currently expect will require significant additional funding.

"The need to raise additional revenues also reflects other fiscal risks that Ireland faces, including our growing reliance on corporation tax as a source of funding."

When asked whether increasing inheritance taxes would be something he was recommending the Government would do, Mr Donohoe replied: "That's not something I would be doing."

Today's Headlines

More Irish News

Download the Sunday World app

Now download the free app for all the latest Sunday World News, Crime, Irish Showbiz and Sport. Available on Apple and Android devices