| 4°C Dublin

Testing times Leaving Cert exams are 'absolutely essential' this year, says top guidance counsellor

Brian Mooney, who is also editor of the Education Matters yearbook, said the system used last year did not work as it should have.


Stock image

Stock image

Stock image

Staging a Leaving Certificate exam of some format this year is “absolutely essential” for students, one of the country’s top guidance counsellors has said.

More than 2,200 pupils will be able to access their marks online from midday today from the deferred Leaving Cert exam last year.

It is estimated that 40 per cent of students are getting higher grades from the deferred exam, than they were offered in predictive grades.

Those who earn more points than in the calculated grades will have the option to start a new higher point course in September.

Brian Mooney, who is also editor of the Education Matters yearbook, said the system used last year did not work as it should have.

"It shows that no matter what system we decide on for this year, having a Leaving Cert exam of some format - at some point, is absolutely essential,” he told Newstalk Breakfast.

He said there is an issue around using class rankings to weigh results.

"Last year the teachers were asked in May to give grades to their students, and they were asked to rank them.

"The Department of Education used a mechanism - the only standardised measure they had last year was the Junior Cert result of the students of 2020."

"So effectively, the teachers were not aware of the value of the class ranking.

"They were awarding grades - but actually when it came to it - the academic ability of the class, calculated based on their Junior Cert results, and the class ranking was determined who got the H1s and who didn't".

"But they were told that the students would never see that.... but what happened effectively was, that under Data Protection, everybody got to see them.

"Therefore, in small rural communities, students therefore knew that the teacher ranked them as number eight".

He added: "You can't run an assessed grade process unless the unions buy into it.

"That's why we're hesitating, that's why there's a meeting this afternoon in which the unions are at the table.

"The Government can't proceed - the Cabinet Sub-Committee's recommendation to full Cabinet - cannot proceed unless you get the unions on-side."

"They both came out yesterday with coded messages basically saying 'We want an exam' - what was really being said in many ways was 'We don't want rankings because we don't want to go back to where we were last year'."

A final decision on the Leaving Certificate is now expected to be made later this week or possibly at next week's Cabinet meeting.

A Government spokesperson said more time is needed to ensure the stakeholders in education are comfortable with the plan.

The Teachers' Union of Ireland (TUI) earlier reiterated its support for holding the 2021 Leaving Certificate exams.

In a statement, the union said it does not believe that a system of calculated grades or similar will reduce stress and anxiety in the school community.

ASTI General Secretary Kieran Christie said the union had been "consistent in our message" that the preferred option for the Leaving Certificate is that it goes ahead, insofar as is possible.

Download the Sunday World app

Now download the free app for all the latest Sunday World News, Crime, Irish Showbiz and Sport. Available on Apple and Android devices

Online Editors

Top Videos