'no reply' | 

Dad who was overpowered by public following alleged knife raids refused bail

‘Don't mess with me. I know what I'm doing’

Central Criminal Court

Tom TuiteSunday World

A FATHER overpowered by members of the public following a string of alleged knife-raids at pharmacies in Dublin has been refused bail.

Brian Carroll, 38, of Holly Road, Donnycarney, Dublin, was charged following his arrest on Friday. He was held overnight at Coolock Garda station and appeared before Judge John Hughes at Dublin District Court on Saturday.

Garda Grainne McDonnell and Detective Garda Clifford Singleton told the court the accused made no reply to the charges. Judge Hughes heard they were objecting to bail due to the seriousness of the case.

Mr Carroll is accused of robbing Bradleys Pharmacy in Artane of assorted prescription drugs worth €404 on November 4.

In the other two alleged raids, he is charged with taking €87 worth of medication from Lalors Pharmacy on Collins Avenue East on November 2 and medication valued €39 from the O'Reilly Pharmacy in Artane.

Garda McDonnell told a contested bail hearing the defendant was allegedly armed with an eight-inch kitchen knife.

She alleged during Friday's robbery, he gave staff a list of drugs and produced the knife, saying, "don't mess with me. I know what I'm doing".

The garda said it would be claimed that he "directed staff into a corner to prevent them seeking help".

A deliveryman in the pharmacy was subjected to aggression and had a knife pointed at him.

The garda voiced concerns about him being released on bail.

She alleged he was caught "red-handed". Garda McDonnell added that she and other gardai saw the accused detained by members of the public at the chemist.

Garda McDonnell told the court she saw him held down, and the knife was present.

The court heard he also brandished the knife, demanded prescribed drugs and engaged in scuffles with the staff of the two other chemists.

Pleading for bail, defence counsel Kevin McCrave said his client lived with and cared for his father.

It was also around the anniversary of his partner's death. The barrister said his client was a father who was "suffering from deep loss", but he would obey conditions if granted bail.

He has not yet indicated how he will plead, and the judge noted he had the presumption of innocence.

However, he refused bail and remanded him in custody pending directions from the Director of Public Prosecutions.

Legal aid was granted to Mr Carroll who was on social welfare.


Today's Headlines

More Courts

Download the Sunday World app

Now download the free app for all the latest Sunday World News, Crime, Irish Showbiz and Sport. Available on Apple and Android devices

WatchMore Videos