NewsCrime Desk

Trial of man accused of vandalising Eamon de Valera grave 'too serious' for lower court

John Moore
John Moore

The trial of a Dublin man accused of vandalising Eamon de Valera's headstone is too serious to be heard at district court level, the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) has decided.

John Moore, 57, of Cherrymount Crescent, Clontarf, was charged earlier with causing criminal damage to Eamon de Valera's headstone and unlawful possession of a hammer in connection with the alleged incident on January 25 last at Glasnevin cemetery in Dublin.

He faced his third hearing at Dublin District Court on Thursday, when the case was listed for directions from the DPP to be given. Judge Anthony Halpin granted the State's application to drop the charge relating to the hammer.

He also heard that the DPP has directed trial on indictment in relation to the criminal damage charge, meaning it is to be heard in the circuit court which has tougher sentencing powers.

Mr Moore asked, "Why is it so severe?", adding that he was offering to plead guilty and he was willing to compensate for the damage.

The De Valera family plot in Glasnevin Cemetery, with Eamon de Valera's grave in the centre

As a condition of bail, he is banned from the graveyard and he said today that this "has been torture" as he has a child buried there.

Judge Halpin noted he has offered to plead guilty and explained to him that the DPP is an independent prosecution officer. He told Mr Moore she has decided that "this is a pretty serious offence, that is why it is going to a judge and jury".

He said the case was being adjourned for six weeks to allow time for the book of evidence to be completed.

Mr Moore, who had not sought professional legal assistance, agreed to the judge's offer today to grant legal aid. Solicitor Peter Connolly was assigned to represent him.

Mr Moore was remanded on continuing bail.

At an earlier hearing he had told the district court: "I just beg for forgiveness, it was a moment of madness, I painfully regret doing it."

His bail terms state he must stay away from all members of the De Valera family, stay away from Glasnevin Cemetery, have no contact with the De Valera family or any of their properties or assets, sign on every Monday, Wednesday and Friday at Clontarf garda station and reside at his current address.

Former taoiseach and Easter 1916 Rising commander Eamon de Valera died in 1975 and was buried in Glasnevin Cemetery.

The graveyard is the final resting place of several key figures in Irish history including Michael Collins, O'Donovan Rossa, Daniel O'Connell, Countess Markievicz and Charles Stewart Parnell.

At his first hearing, on January 26 last, the court heard Mr Moore's reply to the criminal damage charge was "I'm guilty".